Bigcommerce vs Bigcartel

Detailed comparison across 10 dimensions

Winner: Bigcartel

BigCartel clearly comes out ahead of BigCommerce on Staquest's weighted six-dimension score. BigCartel has a free tier; BigCommerce does not. Paid plans start at $39/mo for BigCommerce and $15/mo for BigCartel.

Quick Overview

Overview	BigCommerceFlexible SaaS e-commerce platform for growing businesses.	BigCartelEasy online stores for artists and makers.
Type	hybrid	saas tool
Company	BigCommerce Pty. Ltd.	Big Cartel, LLC
Free Tier
Has API
Open Source
Learning Curve	-	-
Integration	-	-
Trending	Stable	Stable
GitHub Stars	-	-
Industries	MarketingDevelopmentE-CommerceSaaS & Cloud	E-CommerceMarketing
Categories	e-commerce	e-commerce
Website	Visit	Visit

Dimension Scores

Winners by Dimension

Overall Winner

Bigcartel

Bigcommerce: 5.5Bigcartel: 5.8(+3.3 pts)

Pricing Value

Bigcartel15% weight

Bigcommerce

9.0

Bigcartel

9.6

Features

Tie15% weight

Bigcommerce

3.0

Bigcartel

3.0

Free Tier

Bigcartel10% weight

Bigcommerce

2.0

Bigcartel

8.0

Ease of Use

Tie10% weight

Bigcommerce

5.0

Bigcartel

5.0

Scalability

Bigcommerce10% weight

Bigcommerce

10.0

Bigcartel

6.4

Integrations

Tie10% weight

Bigcommerce

8.0

Bigcartel

8.0

API Quality

Tie10% weight

Bigcommerce

6.0

Bigcartel

6.0

Momentum

Tie10% weight

Bigcommerce

3.0

Bigcartel

3.0

Community

Tie5% weight

Bigcommerce

3.0

Bigcartel

3.0

Open Source

Tie5% weight

Bigcommerce

2.0

Bigcartel

2.0

Pricing Comparison

BigCommerce

Standard

~$39/mo

flat

Plus

~$105/mo

flat

Pro

~$399/mo

usage based

Additional $150/month for every $200,000 increment in sales over $400,000

Enterprise

Contact sales

custom

BigCartel

Gold

Free

View pricing

freemium

Accept payment online
Free mobile-friendly shop template
Basic sales reporting
No Big Cartel transaction fees

Platinum

~$15/mo

View pricing

flat

Support for custom domains
Sell digital goods and services
Promote with discount codes
Print shipping labels and track orders
Customize your shop design

Diamond

~$30/mo

View pricing

flat

Recover abandoned carts
Schedule product drops
Password-protect products
Connect to 7,000+ apps with Zapier
Priority support from humans

Feature Comparison

Feature	bigcommerce	bigcartel
Additional $150/Month For Every $200,000 Increment In Sales Over $400,000
Accept Payment Online
Basic Sales Reporting
Connect To 7,000+ Apps With Zapier
Customize Your Shop Design
Free Mobile-Friendly Shop Template
No Big Cartel Transaction Fees
Password-Protect Products
Print Shipping Labels And Track Orders
Priority Support From Humans
Promote With Discount Codes
Recover Abandoned Carts
Schedule Product Drops
Sell Digital Goods And Services
Support For Custom Domains

Showing 15 of 15 features

Dashes mean the feature isn't listed in our data. The tool may still support it.

Frequently asked questions

Is BigCommerce or BigCartel better?

On Staquest's weighted six-dimension scoring, BigCartel comes out ahead overall, though BigCommerce can be the better fit depending on your priorities — see the dimension-by-dimension breakdown above.

Which is cheaper, BigCommerce or BigCartel?

BigCommerce's paid plans start at $39/mo and BigCartel's start at $15/mo, so BigCartel is the lower entry price. Check the pricing comparison for higher tiers and per-seat costs.

Does BigCommerce or BigCartel have a free tier?

BigCartel offers a free tier; BigCommerce does not currently list one.

Which is better for pricing value, BigCommerce or BigCartel?

BigCartel scores higher on pricing value in Staquest's analysis. It is the highest-weighted dimension in this comparison.

View Bigcommerce View Bigcartel